Mirena vs Copper coil: Which one is best?

Deciding which contraception to go on can be a difficult decision, one that might require a few attempts until you find the one that works for you.

Once you have decided what birth control product you would like to try, choosing the brand and type of that particular contraceptive is a decision in itself.

To help you make the best choice for you, and hopefully without having to conduct so much trial and error, The Lowdown lays out the ins and the outs (pun intended) of contraceptives.

This week, we bring you a comparison between the Mirena coil and the Copper coil.

Mirena Coil

The Mirena coil, is a brand of IUS which stands for Intrauterine system. There are several types of IUS but for now, we shall focus on the Mirena. It is made of a white T-shaped frame made from a plastic called polyethylene.

The Mirena coil releases levonorgestrel, a synthetic form of the hormone progesterone, similar to the natural form produced by your ovaries. It thickens the cervical mucus, which makes it more difficult for sperm to move through the opening in the cervix, and thins the lining of the womb so a fertilised egg is less likely to be able to implant itself. For some women it may also stop ovulation.

It is inserted into your womb by a doctor a nurse, an appointment which you can book at your local sexual health clinic or some GP practices.

The Mirena coil can last for up to five years.

IUD or Copper coil

The IUD is a small plastic and copper device that, like the Mirena coil, is T-shaped and is inserted into your womb.

The copper alters the cervical mucus, which makes it more difficult for sperm to reach an egg and survive. It can also stop a fertilised egg from being able to implant itself.

The copper coil can last from five years to up to 10 years depending on which make of coil you have.

Unlike the Mirena coil, the Copper IUD is hormone free.

Advantages of both coils

The copper IUD protects you from pregnancy right away. If the Mirena coil is inserted in the first 7 days of your menstrual cycle you are protected from pregnancy straight away. If it’s fitted at any other time, you need to use additional contraception, such as condoms, for 7 days after.

Once in, you do not have to do anything until you wish for it to be removed or it is due to be replaced.

Both can be used while breastfeeding.

Both are not affected by other medicines.

According to the FPA, the Mirena coil is useful if you can’t use the hormone oestrogen, like in the combined pill, the contraceptive patch and the contraceptive vaginal ring. Similarly the copper IUD does not contain hormones and can also be an option if you cannot take oestrogen.

Both the IUS and IUD are two of the most effective forms of contraception available.

It’s possible to get pregnant as soon as the IUS or IUD is removed.

Side effects of both coils

Despite them protecting you from pregnancy, neither coils prevent you from getting sexually transmitted diseases (STIs).

They could affect your menstrual cycle. For the Mirena coil, some women experience lighter periods or periods which stop altogether. However for the Copper coil, some women experience heavier, longer and more painful periods, though this may improve after a few months.

With the Mirena coil, some women experience side effects such as acne, headaches or breast tenderness, usually in the first few months. Some women also experience changes in mood or libido. There are no hormonal side effects, such as acne, headaches or breast tenderness with the copper IUD.

Although very rare, some women using the IUS can develop small fluid-filled cysts on their ovaries. These usually disappear without treatment.

What do our reviewers say?

One of the great things about The Lowdown is that real contraception users tell us their thoughts on the contraception they have tried, which we hope helps you make a better decision when you are considering going on or coming off one.

For the Mirena coil, more than half (57%) of females said it stopped their periods completely but for the copper coil, the majority (70%) said their periods became heavier.

Nearly half (46%) of reviewers said the Mirena coil neither improved or worsened their moods and 63% said the same for the copper coil.

Just below half (49%) said the Mirena coil caused no change to their sex drive, 11% said it increased and 27% said they felt a loss in their sex drive. For the Copper coil, 70% of females said there was no change in their sex drive, 10% said there was an increase and 13% said there was a drop.

One of the most common side effects when immediately having the Mirena coil put in was vaginal discharge. Of the 47% reviewers who said they had vaginal discharge, 4% said they had it a great deal, 14% quite a bit and 24% a bit.

Likewise, the same side effect was reported as the most common for the Copper coil right after insertion. Of the 47% who said it was a side effect, 9% said they had a great deal of vaginal discharge, 14% quite a bit and 18% a bit.

Mirena vs Copper coil: the reviews

Mirena coil

“I have used the coil for best part of 20 years after my now 20 year old son was born. I would highly recommend, after trying the pill before this, hated that!”

“The day I had it fitted I had THE WORST cramps I have ever had but I did also have some post smear investigations done at the same time so they probably didn’t help. I had irregular bleeding for about 6 weeks due to having my implant removed and coming off the pill at the same time as having this fitted (hormones all over the place!) 3 months ish in and it’s the best thing I ever did! So side effects, no bleeding, no remembering to take anything and covered for 5 years. Bonus I feel so much happier/positive, loss a bit of weigh (I do exercise a lot) and increased sex drive.”

“I waited 2 years before getting the Mirena coil as I had heard so many horror stories. I saved up so I could go privately to a highly experienced gynaecologist as I was petrified about the insertion. I have had 2 babies, but I honestly did not even know she had inserted it! She gave me a numbing injection which didn’t hurt either, maybe that helped. No cramps until the evening which were quite strong, but a hot water bottle and ibuprofen helped. Some greasiness and spots in the first 3 months. However, 6 months later, no periods, no cramps, skin is back to normal, no bloating and a very reliable form of contraception. Best contraception I have used and just wish I had gone for it sooner! Advice would be, get a very experienced professional to insert, and keep with it for 6 months for your body to fully adjust.”

Copper coil

‘No change’

“The insertion was very painful however I think worth it if it works for you in the long term. The positives were no change in hormones so no change in weight, mood and other changes from hormonal contraception. For me it just made my periods too uncomfortable and I also got thrush and cystitis. I’ve heard since that it is better for women who have had children so maybe that was why.”

‘Painful insertion’

Insertion was painful and I did feel faint during the procedure but it was quick and i felt better after about 10 mins. Since then my periods have been heavier but no change in PMS, pain or cramps and more importantly to me no change to mood, skin, weight or libido like hormonal contraception can do. Very happy with the copper coil, I can tolerate slightly heavier periods and don’t have to worry about pregnancy or the hormonal side effects of other methods.”

‘Terrible cramping’

“The Paragard was great in some ways but it caused me terrible cramping, heavy periods (I mean like soak a super sized tampon in an hour, which normally for me wouldn’t happen even in a day), and worst of all chronic, recurrent yeast and bv infections. I have had it out for more than a year and seem to have permanently altered my vaginal Microbiome as I am still getting the occasional infection. Worst decision of my life. If you’re cool with risking long term dysbiosis, go for it, as it is a well documented side effect. Otherwise, stay away.”

Sources:

www.nhs.uk

www.fpa.org.uk

Published and last reviewed on 15/01/21 in line with our content policy.

This guide was brought to you by The Lowdown. We are the world’s first contraception review platform, providing real-life experiences from thousands of reviews collected from our community of men and women.

Why not leave us a review of your contraceptive experience? Whether you’ve got good things to say about the Mirena coil or had trouble with implant removal, we want to hear about it! Tell us about your experience and help people around the world find the right method for them.